ONLINE THERAPY SERVING ALL OF SOUTH CAROLINA

Carolina Behavioral Counseling Blog

Setting Healthy Boundaries as a Chronic People-Pleaser

If the thought of saying “no” makes your stomach turn, you’re not alone. As a people-pleaser, you might feel like keeping everyone happy is your responsibility—even when it leaves you drained. I hate to tell you, but constantly putting others first isn’t just exhausting; it’s unsustainable. 

Learning to set boundaries is about more than saying no—it’s about protecting your energy, respecting your limits, and strengthening your relationships. 

What is a People-Pleaser?

A people-pleaser is someone who prioritizes others’ needs and wants over their own, often to avoid conflict or to seek approval. Does this sound familiar? Maybe you’re the friend who always says yes to plans, even when you’re exhausted. Or the coworker who takes on extra tasks to avoid disappointing your boss. While it might feel noble, people-pleasing often leads to burnout, resentment, and strained relationships.

If you find yourself constantly overcommitted or struggling to voice your own needs, it’s time to rethink how you approach boundaries.

Why People-Pleasers Struggle With Boundaries

Guilt is one of the biggest reasons people-pleasers have a hard time setting boundaries. You might feel like saying no makes you selfish or unkind. But the reality is that boundaries are essential for healthy relationships and your well-being. Without them, you’re more likely to feel overwhelmed, taken advantage of, or disconnected from your true self.

People-pleasers also fear pushback. Maybe you’re worried about how someone will react if you say no or assert your needs. But the discomfort of setting a boundary is temporary compared to the long-term benefits it brings.

Signs You Need to Set Boundaries

Still not sure if you need boundaries? Here are some common signs:

  • You feel resentful after saying yes to something.
  • You avoid conflict at all costs, even when it means ignoring your own feelings.
  • You’re constantly exhausted or overwhelmed.
  • You struggle to prioritize your own needs or desires.
  • You feel like people take advantage of your kindness.

If any of these resonate, it’s time to take a step back and reevaluate your limits.

A young woman journaling her thoughts, reflecting on breaking free from people-pleaser habits and focusing on setting healthy boundaries.

How to Set Boundaries Without “People-Pleaser” Guilt

1. Start Small

If you’re new to setting boundaries, don’t overwhelm yourself by tackling big situations right away. Start with low-stakes scenarios, like declining an invitation to an event you’re not interested in. As you practice, it will become easier to say no in more challenging situations.

2. Get Clear on Your Limits

Before you can set boundaries, you need to know what they are. Ask yourself:

  • What drains my energy?
  • What am I saying yes to out of obligation rather than desire?
  • Where am I overcommitting?

Write these down to clarify where your boundaries need to be.

3. Be Direct and Kind

When setting a boundary, aim for clarity and kindness. For example, instead of making excuses, say: “I can’t take on any more projects right now, but I’d be happy to revisit this in the future.” Being honest shows respect for both yourself and the other person.

4. Anticipate Pushback

Not everyone will immediately respect your boundaries, especially if they’re used to you saying yes. Stay firm and repeat your boundary if necessary. For instance: “I understand this is important to you, but I really can’t commit to that right now.”

5. Reframe Guilt

Feeling guilty after setting a boundary is normal for people-pleasers, but guilt doesn’t mean you’ve done something wrong. Remind yourself that boundaries aren’t selfish—they’re a form of self-respect.

What to Do When You’re Met With Resistance

When someone pushes back against your boundary, it’s easy to second-guess yourself. Here’s how to handle it:

  1. Stay Calm: Take a deep breath and remind yourself why you set the boundary in the first place.
  2. Repeat Your Boundary: Stick to your original statement and avoid over-explaining. For example: “I can’t commit to that right now.”
  3. Stand Firm: If the person continues to push, it’s okay to disengage from the conversation. You’re not responsible for their reaction.

How Boundaries Improve Relationships

At first, it might feel like boundaries create distance, but they actually strengthen relationships. Here’s how:

  • Encourages Mutual Respect: When you communicate your needs, it sets the tone for others to respect them.
  • Prevents Resentment: Boundaries reduce feelings of being taken for granted.
  • Fosters Authenticity: You can show up as your true self instead of constantly trying to please others.

Healthy relationships thrive when both parties feel valued and respected—boundaries make that possible.

A Reminder for People-Pleasers

Breaking free from the people-pleaser mindset takes time and practice, so be patient with yourself. Celebrate small wins, like saying no without feeling guilty or asserting your needs in a conversation. Over time, these small steps will add up, and you’ll feel more confident in prioritizing yourself.

Remember, setting boundaries isn’t about shutting people out—it’s about letting them in without losing yourself. You deserve relationships that uplift you, not drain you.


by Samm Brenner Gautier, LPC, LPCS-C

Samantha Brenner Gautier, LPC, LPCS-C. Founder of Carolina Behavioral Counseling

Hi, I'm Samm, a Licensed Professional Counselor (LPC), Supervisor (LPCS-C), and the founder of Carolina Behavioral Counseling. Our group practice is grounded in the fundamental belief that young adults should feel confident, capable, and in control when dealing with anxiety and other mental health challenges.

Let's Connect: Instagram icon

Thank you for subscribing!